Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
 
2
 
3
Categories
    • Original Research Papers
    • Survey Papers
4
Research Papers
  • Describe novel technical results
    • An algorithm
    • System Construct : Hardware Design, Software System, Protocol
    • A performance evaluation – analysis, simulation, measurement
    • A theory – collection of theorems


5
Research Papers
  • Should focus on
    • Results should be described sufficiently so that their validity can be established.
    • Novel aspects should be identified
    • Significance of results should be identified : Improvements and impacts


6
Paper Structure
7
Paper Structure
  • Title
    • Avoid all but the most readily understood abbreviations.
    • Avoid common phrases like "novel" etc.
    • Use adjectives that describe the distinctive features of your work, e.g., reliable, scalable, high-performance, robust, low-complexity, or low-cost.
    • Consult Automatic Systems Research Topic or Paper Title Generator.
8
Paper Structure
  • Abstract
    • 200 words approx
    • A summary of the paper, including a brief description of the problem, the solution, and conclusions.
    • Do not cite references in the abstract.


  • Keywords
    • They should be selected such that a computerized search is facilitated.


9
Paper Structure
  • Introduction
    • Introduce problem
    • Outline solution
    • The statement of the problem should include a clear statement why the problem is important (or interesting).
    • The proposed solution should be briefly described, with explanations of how it is different from, and superior to, existing solutions.
    • The last paragraph should be a summary of what will be described in each subsequent section of the paper.
10
Paper Structure
  • Related Work
    • This should contain the background of the problem, why it is important, and what others have done to solve this problem.


    • All related existing work should be properly described and referenced.
11
Paper Structure
  • Body of paper
    • Problem Solution / System model
      • The proposed model is described. Assumptions??


      • State the model assumptions clearly. Do the assumptions make sense?


      • Even if assumptions to make the problem mathematically tractable, they should reflect some real-world situations.


      • Instances where the assumptions hold should be described.


      • Use figures to help explain the model.
12
Paper Structure
  • Body of paper
    • Sufficient motivation, example scenarios,


    • Example scenarios with Illustrating figures.


    • General evaluations of your algorithm or architecture, e.g., material proving that the algorithm is O(log N), go here, not in the evaluation section.


    • Realization: contains actual implementation details when implementing architecture isn't totally straightforward. Mention briefly implementation language, platform, location, dependencies on other packages and minimum resource usage if pertinent.
13
Paper Structure
  • Conclusions
    • This summarizes what have been done and concluded based on the results.
    • A description of future research should also be included

  • References
    • This should contain a list of papers referred to in the paper.
    • Choose a more readily available reference.
    • Research reports, internal memos, private correspondences, and preprints should be avoided.
    • Often journal editors tend to pick reviewers from the authors of the references cited in the submission.
14
Hints and Notes
  • Write like a newspaper report, You saw this, then u saw that.. Then u inference that…
  • Use simple language structures, small sentences.
  • Don’t Cheat. (You will be caught eventually)
  • For each sentence ask yourself, could it be misread? How? What is the best way to fix it?
  • If you read what you have written assuming only the knowledge that the reader can be expected to have, does each part work the way you intended?
  • If you read it aloud, does it sound the way you intended?


15
Referee Evaluation Issues
  • Will this advance the state of the art?
  • Did you learn anything new?
  • Does it provide evidence which supports/contradicts hypotheses?
  • Experimental validation?
  • Will the paper generate discussion at the conference?
  • How readable is the paper?
  • Is the paper relevant to a broader community?
16
Survey Paper

  • A paper that summarizes and organizes recent research results in a novel way that integrates and adds understanding to work in the field.
17
Survey Paper
  • A survey paper assumes a general knowledge of the area.
  • It emphasizes the classification of the existing literature, developing a perspective on the area, and evaluating trends.


  • Evaluation Criterion
  • Thoroughness and scope of survey
  • Classification and organization of trends
  • Critical evaluation of approaches (relative advantage/disadvantages)
  • Quality of explanation (Draw your own figures, diagram, charts)
  • Reference and Pointer to depth information


18
References
  • Victor O. K. Li, "Hints on Writing Technical Papers and Making Presentations", IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON EDUCATION, VOL. 42, NO. 2, MAY 1999.
  • Ron Dusterhoft, Halliburton, and Jim Giddens, "How To Write Technical Papers and Journal Articles", Pillars of the Industry Journal
19
Questions ??
  • Thanks…